Which Should You Choose?
CoverGirl × Maybelline New York
Looks good on the shelf. But what about on paper?
We've lined up the facts - CoverGirl vs. Maybelline New York,
scored across what actually matters.
✨ Better Choice
C
CoverGirl
Accessible color cosmetics across face, eyes, and lips with Leaping Bunny–certified cruelty-free formulas.
OVERALL SCORE
Industry Average
People
Planet
Animals
Evidence-based analysis across our comprehensive framework
M
Maybelline New York
A mass‑market cosmetics brand known for its diverse and accessible range of makeup essentials infused with on‑trend formulations.
OVERALL SCORE
Industry Average
People
Planet
Animals
Evidence-based analysis across our comprehensive framework
Detailed Sustainability Breakdown
Line-by-line comparison across all 15 PPA criteria
| CoverGirl | Maybelline New York | |
|---|---|---|
|
🧍 People
|
||
| Ingredient Safety ? |
|
|
| Labor Practices ? |
|
|
| Marketing Integrity ? |
|
|
| Social Impact ? |
|
|
| Supply Chain Transparency ? |
|
|
|
🌍 Planet
|
||
| Biodiversity Protection ? |
|
|
| Chemical Responsibility ? |
|
|
| Climate Action ? |
|
|
| Packaging Sustainability ? |
|
|
| Water Stewardship ? |
|
|
|
🐾 Animals
|
||
| Conservation Support ? |
|
|
| Cruelty Free Standards ? |
|
|
| Sustainable Sourcing ? |
|
|
| Vegan Options ? |
|
|
| Wildlife Impact ? |
|
|
Legend:
Strong performance
Moderate performance
Weak performance
Final Results
CoverGirl wins with stronger sustainability practices across multiple categories, leading by 1.0 points overall.
Ready to Shop CoverGirl?
Find CoverGirl products through our trusted retail partners
We earn commissions from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
Brands may not be available from all retailers.
Brands may not be available from all retailers.