Tom's of Maine
Learn more about our scoring →
About Tom's of Maine
Tom's of Maine stands as one of the pioneering natural personal care brands since 1970, building market leadership in toothpaste, deodorants, and oral care products positioned as free from artificial additives. Available at major retailers including Target, the brand has established significant mainstream presence as an accessible natural alternative, though recent developments reveal concerning gaps between marketing claims and actual product safety standards that challenge its foundational natural positioning.
The brand's sustainability performance presents a troubling dichotomy of genuine environmental commitments undermined by serious chemical safety and marketing integrity failures. While Tom's of Maine demonstrates legitimate climate leadership through science-based net-zero emissions targets by 2040 and renewable energy adoption, verified PFAS contamination in mouthwash products and documented greenwashing violations over packaging claims expose fundamental oversight gaps that contradict the brand's natural product foundation and consumer trust.
Operating under Colgate-Palmolive ownership since 2006, Tom's of Maine benefits from corporate sustainability infrastructure including supplier responsible sourcing protocols and environmental monitoring systems. The parent company relationship provides B Corporation certification since 2019 and access to broader sustainability resources, though this framework has proven insufficient to prevent the chemical safety failures and marketing integrity violations that now define the brand's current sustainability challenges rather than its historical natural product legacy.
The Good Stuff
Where Tom's of Maine appears to be making meaningful progress. We cross-referenced these findings with multiple independent sources.
Verified Cruelty-Free Standards
Maintains rigorous cruelty-free certification through independent third-party verification with confirmed policies prohibiting animal testing across all ingredient sourcing and product development
Science-Based Climate Targets
Demonstrates measurable environmental commitment through net-zero greenhouse gas emissions goals by 2040 supported by 100% renewable electricity implementation at manufacturing facilities
B Corporation Accountability Framework
Certified B Corporation since 2019 providing verified social and environmental performance standards with regular third-party assessment and transparency requirements
The Reality Check
Areas where the publicly available data gets murky, incomplete, or concerning. We're transparent about the limitations of our analysis.
Verified Chemical Safety Failures
PFAS contamination confirmed in Wicked Fresh mouthwash products with active class-action investigations exposing fundamental gaps in harmful substance screening despite natural product positioning
Documented Marketing Integrity Violations
Legal challenges over misleading recyclable packaging claims and deceptive natural product marketing demonstrate systematic greenwashing practices that undermine consumer trust and transparency standards
Comprehensive Environmental Program Gaps
Complete absence of biodiversity protection, water stewardship programs, and wildlife conservation initiatives represents significant missed opportunities for holistic environmental impact beyond climate action
Tom's of Maine's
Impact Aura
A visual representation of Tom's of Maine's positive impact
across People, Planet and Animals
Each colored area represents the brand's performance in that sustainability category. The size and intensity of each blob corresponds to their score—larger, more vibrant areas indicate stronger performance.
Our Research
Key findings from our comprehensive analysis of Tom's of Maine's sustainability performance across People, Planet & Animals impact.
Positive Impact on People
Research Highlights
- PFAS contamination verified in Wicked Fresh mouthwash products with active class-action investigations and pending lawsuits demonstrating serious chemical safety failures
- Marketing integrity significantly compromised by documented greenwashing over recyclable packaging claims and misleading natural product positioning
- Labor practices operate through parent company Colgate-Palmolive's supplier responsible sourcing assessments with environmental health and safety monitoring protocols
- Supply chain oversight managed through Colgate's established responsible sourcing framework with supplier assessment requirements
- Social impact programming limited to parent company initiatives rather than brand-specific community engagement or impact measurement
Evidence Strength
Exceptionally strong documentation for ingredient safety failures and marketing integrity violations, solid verification for labor practices through parent company systems
Positive Impact on Planet
Research Highlights
- Climate action demonstrates measurable commitment through net-zero greenhouse gas emissions targets by 2040 and 100% renewable electricity adoption at manufacturing sites
- Chemical responsibility severely compromised by verified PFAS presence in consumer products indicating fundamental gaps in harmful substance screening and quality control
- Packaging innovation achieves 100% recycled plastic implementation in deodorant containers while facing legal challenges over misleading recyclability claims
- Biodiversity protection completely absent with no habitat restoration initiatives, conservation partnerships, or ecosystem impact mitigation programs
- Water stewardship shows no disclosed conservation programs, facility-level usage metrics, or watershed protection initiatives
Evidence Strength
Strong documentation for climate commitments contrasted with verified chemical safety failures, significant gaps in biodiversity and water stewardship programs
Positive Impact on Animals
Research Highlights
- Cruelty-free certification rigorously verified through independent third-party audit programs with confirmed no-testing policies across all product development
- Vegan product availability limited to select formulations without comprehensive brand-wide certification or transparent scope definition
- Wildlife conservation impact demonstrates complete absence of habitat protection partnerships, species preservation funding, or biodiversity conservation initiatives
- Sustainable sourcing protocols reference animal-derived ingredients through parent company assessments but lack independent verification standards
- Conservation funding shows no disclosed financial support for wildlife protection organizations or ecosystem preservation efforts
Evidence Strength
Comprehensive third-party verification for cruelty-free standards, limited documentation for vegan claims and absent wildlife conservation programming
See the Receipts
We don't just make claims—here are the official certifications that prove Tom's of Maine's sustainability commitments.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Tom's of Maine sustainable?
Tom's of Maine presents a complex sustainability profile with legitimate climate commitments including net-zero emissions targets by 2040, but faces serious challenges from verified PFAS contamination in products and documented marketing integrity violations. The brand's B Corporation certification and cruelty-free standards demonstrate some environmental accountability, while chemical safety failures and greenwashing issues require immediate resolution to align with sustainable business practices.
Is Tom's of Maine cruelty-free?
Yes, Tom's of Maine maintains verified cruelty-free certification through rigorous independent third-party audit programs with confirmed policies prohibiting animal testing on both ingredients and finished products. This certification represents one of the brand's most reliable sustainability commitments with strong verification standards.
Does Tom's of Maine have clean ingredients?
Tom's of Maine's ingredient safety profile shows significant concerns that contradict its natural product positioning. Verified PFAS contamination in Wicked Fresh mouthwash products with active class-action investigations demonstrates serious chemical oversight failures that compromise the brand's clean ingredient claims and consumer safety standards.
Is Tom's of Maine carbon neutral?
Tom's of Maine has established science-based climate targets including net-zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2040 and currently operates manufacturing facilities with 100% renewable electricity. While not yet carbon neutral, the brand demonstrates measurable progress toward comprehensive decarbonization through verified renewable energy adoption.
Is Tom's of Maine a B Corp?
Yes, Tom's of Maine has maintained Certified B Corporation status since March 2019, providing verified social and environmental performance standards with regular third-party assessment requirements. This certification framework offers accountability measures, though recent chemical safety and marketing integrity issues challenge the brand's ability to meet B Corp standards consistently.
Are Tom's of Maine products vegan?
Tom's of Maine offers select vegan product options but lacks comprehensive brand-wide vegan certification or transparent scope definition. The brand's sustainable sourcing assessments reference animal-derived ingredients through parent company protocols, requiring consumers to verify individual product formulations for vegan compliance.
Is Tom's of Maine greenwashing?
Evidence suggests Tom's of Maine engages in greenwashing practices through misleading recyclable packaging claims and deceptive natural product marketing facing legal challenges. These documented marketing integrity violations, combined with verified PFAS contamination issues, indicate systematic gaps between environmental claims and actual product safety performance.
Ready to Shop Tom's of Maine?
Find Tom's of Maine products through our trusted retail partners
Brands That Score Better
The Bottom Line
Tom's of Maine exemplifies the sustainability challenges facing heritage natural brands—legitimate environmental commitments including science-based climate targets and verified cruelty-free standards fundamentally undermined by serious chemical safety failures and documented marketing integrity violations. The verified PFAS contamination in mouthwash products and legal challenges over greenwashing claims require immediate resolution before the brand can credibly align its sustainability performance with its natural product positioning and B Corporation accountability framework.