Milani
Learn more about our scoring →
About Milani
Milani represents a compelling case study in affordable color cosmetics accessibility, having established itself as a drugstore brand that delivers professional-quality formulations since 2001. The brand's acquisition by private equity firm Gryphon Investors signals institutional confidence in its market position, particularly within the competitive foundation and face makeup categories where shade inclusivity increasingly drives consumer loyalty.
From a sustainability perspective, Milani demonstrates selective commitment areas alongside significant transparency gaps that reflect broader industry challenges. The brand's dual cruelty-free certification through independent verification programs represents genuine ethical positioning, while its substantial vegan product portfolio—approximately 70% of offerings—suggests responsiveness to evolving consumer values, though some formulations retain traditional animal-derived ingredients. However, the complete absence of environmental certifications and comprehensive disclosure—from climate targets to supply chain transparency—indicates substantial opportunities for advancement.
Operating within the Gryphon Investors portfolio, Milani benefits from private equity resources that could facilitate sustainability infrastructure development, though current evidence suggests these capabilities remain largely untapped for environmental and social impact initiatives.
The Good Stuff
Where Milani appears to be making meaningful progress. We cross-referenced these findings with multiple independent sources.
Dual Third-Party Cruelty-Free Verification
Certified cruelty-free through both Leaping Bunny and PETA verification programs, with comprehensive no-testing policies and exclusion from markets requiring animal testing
Substantial Vegan Product Selection
Over 50 vegan formulations representing approximately 70% of brand offerings, providing extensive plant-based alternatives while maintaining some traditional formulations
Authentic Shade Inclusivity Leadership
Foundation range spanning 45 shades from fair through deep skin tones, addressing genuine diversity needs in affordable color cosmetics
The Reality Check
Areas where the publicly available data gets murky, incomplete, or concerning. We're transparent about the limitations of our analysis.
Complete Environmental Certification Absence
No climate, green chemistry, water stewardship, or biodiversity certifications, with absence of science-based targets or renewable energy initiatives
Supply Chain Transparency Gaps
Absence of disclosed sourcing standards for key ingredients including mica, palm oil, and shea, limiting accountability for ethical procurement
Chemical Safety Policy Limitations
No comprehensive PFAS policy or third-party green chemistry certification, despite basic microbead avoidance practices
Milani's
Impact Aura
A visual representation of Milani's positive impact
across People, Planet and Animals
Each colored area represents the brand's performance in that sustainability category. The size and intensity of each blob corresponds to their score—larger, more vibrant areas indicate stronger performance.
Our Research
Key findings from our comprehensive analysis of Milani's sustainability performance across People, Planet & Animals impact.
Positive Impact on People
Research Highlights
- Marketing integrity demonstrates dual cruelty-free certification through independent third-party verification programs
- Ingredient safety shows selective allergen-free formulations through independent safety database review
- Supply chain transparency lacks disclosure standards for mica, palm oil, and shea ingredient sourcing
- Labor practices show absence of third-party certification or auditing verification systems
- Social impact initiatives remain undocumented with no verifiable community investment programs
Evidence Strength
Strong documentation for cruelty-free verification and selective safety data, significant gaps in supply chain and labor transparency
Positive Impact on Planet
Research Highlights
- Chemical responsibility demonstrates microbead avoidance but lacks comprehensive green-chemistry certification
- Packaging practices utilize conventional plastic materials without sustainable innovation documentation
- Climate action shows absence of science-based targets, renewable energy commitments, or emissions reporting
- Water stewardship initiatives lack documentation of conservation efforts or facility-level metrics
- Biodiversity protection programs remain undisclosed with no habitat conservation partnerships
Evidence Strength
Limited documentation with basic chemical avoidance practices, comprehensive gaps across environmental impact areas including absence of environmental certifications
Positive Impact on Animals
Research Highlights
- Cruelty-free certification verified through dual independent third-party programs with comprehensive no-testing policies
- Vegan product offerings include over 50 formulations representing approximately 70% of brand portfolio
- Geographic market strategy excludes regions requiring animal testing for cosmetic sales
- Non-vegan formulations contain traditional animal-derived ingredients including beeswax, carmine, and lanolin
- Wildlife conservation support shows absence of funding partnerships or environmental protection initiatives
Evidence Strength
Excellent verification for cruelty-free standards and substantial vegan offerings, mixed portfolio with some animal-derived ingredients, limited documentation for broader animal welfare initiatives
See the Receipts
We don't just make claims—here are the official certifications that prove Milani's sustainability commitments.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Milani cruelty-free and sustainable?
Milani demonstrates strong animal welfare standards with dual cruelty-free certification through independent verification programs including Leaping Bunny and PETA. However, broader sustainability performance shows significant gaps, particularly with complete absence of environmental certifications and limited supply chain transparency. The brand excels in cruelty-free practices while lacking comprehensive environmental initiatives.
Does Milani offer vegan makeup options?
Milani provides over 50 vegan formulations representing approximately 70% of their product portfolio. While offering substantial plant-based options, the brand is not fully vegan and some formulations contain traditional animal-derived ingredients such as beeswax, carmine, and lanolin.
Is Milani safe for sensitive skin?
Independent safety database reviews indicate select Milani products meet allergen-free criteria, though the brand lacks comprehensive PFAS policies or third-party green chemistry certification. Consumers with specific sensitivities should review individual product formulations and ingredient lists.
What makes Milani an inclusive beauty brand?
Milani demonstrates authentic inclusivity through their foundation range spanning 45 shades from fair through deep skin tones, addressing genuine diversity needs in affordable color cosmetics. This shade range represents substantive commitment beyond surface-level diversity initiatives.
How does Milani compare to other budget-friendly makeup brands?
Milani's dual cruelty-free certification and substantial vegan portfolio distinguish it within the budget cosmetics category. However, the brand shows complete absence of environmental certifications compared to sustainability-focused alternatives, making it suitable for consumers prioritizing animal welfare over comprehensive environmental impact.
Does Milani use sustainable packaging?
Current evidence indicates Milani utilizes conventional plastic packaging without documented sustainable innovation initiatives. The brand avoids microbeads but lacks comprehensive packaging sustainability programs, recycled content commitments, or environmental packaging certifications.
What certifications does Milani have?
Milani holds verified cruelty-free certifications from both Leaping Bunny and PETA, representing independent third-party verification of their no-testing policies. The brand currently lacks any environmental, labor, or broader sustainability certifications.
Ready to Shop Milani?
Find Milani products through our trusted retail partners
Brands That Score Better
The Bottom Line
Milani delivers genuine value in animal welfare standards through verified cruelty-free practices and substantial vegan offerings (approximately 70% of portfolio), while complete absence of environmental certifications and transparency gaps limit broader sustainability performance. The brand represents a solid choice for consumers prioritizing animal ethics within budget-friendly color cosmetics, though comprehensive sustainability seekers may find limited environmental accountability.
Compare Brands
See how Milani stacks up against similar brands